OMG! Run and RUN FAST!! That salesman is out to lunch. All the weights come into play when towing.
Also, I would take a good look into the statistics on gas vs diesel. I have seen many comparisons of the two and over time, the diesel is cheaper to operate. I know it is hard to understand but when looking at the breakdown of maintenance, fuel cost, oil changes, repair over time, the diesel wins out.
Either way, like others have said, go to at least a 350 or 3500. I had a 250 and had to trade up due to weight restrictions. Yes, the 250 with the 6.7L would pull a house but the cargo capacity is what hurt me. With the 350 sent from 2740 to 4114. Long bed is also a much better ride as the 350 has 176" wheel base. The towing capacity is also important. Just because it says it can tow 10,000 doesn't mean it will comfortably.
Not sure about Chev or GMC but I know my F350 has 500HP and 1200 lbs torque. AND I'm getting right at 12 MPG towing. You can't beat that!
Of course it is your choice but like was said, from a 1/2 ton to 3/4 ton is not much difference in price. And I am sold on diesel for towing.
Happy Glamping!
OMG! Run and RUN FAST!! That salesman is out to lunch. All the weights come into play when towing.
Also, I would take a good look into the statistics on gas vs diesel. I have seen many comparisons of the two and over time, the diesel is cheaper to operate. I know it is hard to understand but when looking at the breakdown of maintenance, fuel cost, oil changes, repair over time, the diesel wins out.
Either way, like others have said, go to at least a 350 or 3500. I had a 250 and had to trade up due to weight restrictions. Yes, the 250 with the 6.7L would pull a house but the cargo capacity is what hurt me. With the 350 sent from 2740 to 4114. Long bed is also a much better ride as the 350 has 176" wheel base. The towing capacity is also important. Just because it says it can tow 10,000 doesn't mean it will comfortably.
Not sure about Chev or GMC but I know my F350 has 500HP and 1200 lbs torque. AND I'm getting right at 12 MPG towing. You can't beat that!
Of course it is your choice but like was said, from a 1/2 ton to 3/4 ton is not much difference in price. And I am sold on diesel for towing.
Happy Glamping!
I actually just watched a video on YouTube of two guys, one driving gas and one driving diesel (both 2500) and they drove a 1100 + mile loop. They filled up before and also after. The diesel was $2.50 cheaper. They were on Colorado and 87 octane gas was $4.189/gal and diesel was $4.999/gal.
That did not take into account the cost of the DEF. I've also read that diesel uses a lot more oil and is more costly to repair (is this true?). Plus you have the extra $10K tacked onto the price. Since I am aiming to buy two new "things" I do need to keep the extra $10K in mind. Plus both diesel and gas are more expensive than usual for the time being.
Please keep the info coming. I will initially be towing only twice a year, RI to TX and TX to RI; 4 days / 3 nights each way. In between I drive very little. I work from home and am a hermit for the most part. I won't be retiring until 2030.
Here are the numbers I have compiled from various PDFs and websites online (I think I captured them correctly but I don't know if they are actually correct) in order to compare - not from actual vehicles, but okay for a gross comparison. They are all for 4WD, crew cab, 20" wheels and long bed, where I was able to specify it. Wheelbase is 172" on all. Both gas & diesel have 36 gal tanks. Some of the numbers may not "add up" correctly because I've been pulling them from where I can find them.
GAS - 2500 HD
GVWR 11,050
GCWR 26,000 lbs
Max tow (bumper pull) 16,000 lbs
Torque 464 ft lbs @4000 RPM
HP 401 @5200 RPM
Rear axle 3.73
Curb weight (LT) 6739 lbs
Max payload (LT) 3523 lbs
Curb weight (LTZ) 7047 lbs
Max payload (LTZ) 3565 lbs
I included LTZ because a lot of the available trucks have it.
DIESEL - 2500 HD - SRW (I am not considering the config with dual tires on back)
GVWR 11,500
GCWR 26,000 or 27,500 lbs - it wasn't clear which number went with what
Max tow (bumper pull) 18,500 lbs
Torque 975 ft lbs @ 1600 RPM
HP 470 @2800 RPM
Rear axle 3.42
Curb weight 7736
Max payload ?
DIESEL - 2500 HD - SRW, with NHT max towing pkg
From what I understand this is basically a 3500 with 2500 badging. I read that, in some states, you would otherwise have to have a CDL for the 3500 - no idea if that is true. When I look up specs for a 3500 diesel, the numbers are the same.
GCWR 30,000 lbs
Max tow (bumper pull) 20,000 lbs
I don't have as much detail like payload and curb weights on everything yet.
GAS - 3500 HD
Mostly the same as the 2500 gas engine
GCWR 26,000
Max tow (bumper pull) 16,000 lbs
HP 401 @ 5200 RPM
Torque 464
Curb weight 7524 (LT & LTZ)
Payload 6428 lbs (LT & LTZ)
Diesel - 3500 HD
Same as 2500 with diesel engine & max tow package
I have read that Ford and Ram have higher ratings.
Also, I don't mind a bumpy ride. I grew up driving a truck & towing a horse trailer all over TX.
Thank you!