• Click here to access some of the presentations made during the 2022 National Rally

Fifth wheel hitch type ?

Flyer32RLS

Member
Buy a $100,000+ trailer, hook to a $100,000 truck and Then brag about the couple hundred bucks ”saved” on a cheap hitch…. too each his own.
Funny, didn't read anywhere that price was the issue. The 220 lbs difference between a "heavy duty" hitch and the Anderson is more than just a convenience. If you have an A frame hoist to remove it then good on ya! I don't and love the Anderson. Glad you like lugging all that extra cargo weight around. I don't!
Happy Glamping!!
 

Midnight Rider

Well-known member
Let's discuss the failure of my ABS module on my 2019 3500 Silverado.
The part is on back order from the dealer! Quoted 2 weeks up till a year for a replacement. Found a used one.
All was good until we learned the used part could only be programmed at the dealer. What a Fiasco!
$1100.00 and 4 days later it's fixed and ABS light is off!
Could you still tow and drive it while ABS was out of order?
 

M and E

Well-known member
Taking the convo in a slightly different direction, any of you all towing with the Gen Y executive? If so, what are your opinions, experiences, etc. I have a 24 F350 CC SB. I'm pulling a 340RL. I would like to think I am pretty certain that I am going this route but always willing to learn (I've never towed with a gooseneck, lots of towing over my life though). I'd also use the offset puck.


 

Flyer32RLS

Member
Taking the convo in a slightly different direction, any of you all towing with the Gen Y executive? If so, what are your opinions, experiences, etc. I have a 24 F350 CC SB. I'm pulling a 340RL. I would like to think I am pretty certain that I am going this route but always willing to learn (I've never towed with a gooseneck, lots of towing over my life though). I'd also use the offset puck.


I heard that some manufactures will void your warranty if the goose neck is used. Something to do with fram twisting. Not for sure just read about it on another site.
 

Midnight Rider

Well-known member
Funny, didn't read anywhere that price was the issue. The 220 lbs difference between a "heavy duty" hitch and the Anderson is more than just a convenience. If you have an A frame hoist to remove it then good on ya! I don't and love the Anderson. Glad you like lugging all that extra cargo weight around. I don't!
Happy Glamping!!
I like the Hitch weight in the back over the tires during the winter. Makes the 3500 HD strong in snow, like a tank!
I have seen one of those Anderson pop out hitches cracked in half wile going down the road. I’ll take the Pull Rite any day.
 

M and E

Well-known member
I heard that some manufactures will void your warranty if the goose neck is used. Something to do with fram twisting. Not for sure just read about it on another site.
I've read that also. However, after reading about other's experiences I cannot find anyone with an issue attributable to the Gen Y, which of course does not mean there may be some. I think the issue cited is torsional flex, which the Gen Y has more than most traditional fifth wheel hitches. All that said, Gen Y is working with Lippert, and is reportedly close to certifying the Gen Y on their frames. What is interesting about what is reported to be holding up the process...money...Lippert wanted exclusive distribution rights of Gen Y as part of the approval deal (on the internet so could be conjecture).
 
Last edited:

Bozo

Well-known member
Funny, didn't read anywhere that price was the issue. The 220 lbs difference between a "heavy duty" hitch and the Anderson is more than just a convenience. If you have an A frame hoist to remove it then good on ya! I don't and love the Anderson. Glad you like lugging all that extra cargo weight around. I don't!
Happy Glamping!!
When the truck already weighs 9k plus….a couple hundred pounds doesn‘t matter much. Truck is meant to pull, not hyper-mile. Hitch stays in the truck 100% of the time. All my goosenecks have kingpins now, much easier and faster hook up and disconnect as well.
 

M and E

Well-known member
When the truck already weighs 9k plus….a couple hundred pounds doesn‘t matter much. Truck is meant to pull, not hyper-mile. Hitch stays in the truck 100% of the time. All my goosenecks have kingpins now, much easier and faster hook up and disconnect as well.
I have a question. Are you saying it is easier to connect and disconnect with a traditional hitch and kingpin or gooseneck conversion like Gen Y? Thanks.
 

M and E

Well-known member
One more thing. I currently have a B&W slider, well I had to destroy it to get a replacement shipped (not complaining). I know this is not a maintenance item per B&W, but there are 8 bearings, shaped like an hourglass (I would call them sheave bearings, but not sure if that is correct). They are in the carriage that sits on the rails. All four of the bearings on the top seized. It was a bear to move the carriage while hitched. Anyhow, it may have been over-torqued or it could have been sensitive to corrosion (which i observed). In any case, B&W is replacing the hitch, no questions asked. Might want to spray those rollers top and bottom. I cannot see it hurting. Maybe lube all 8.
 

Bozo

Well-known member
I'm new to this so not being snarky, legit question. Why?
kingpin vs ball. one motion to lock in. With ball you must stop very close to center of socket on trailer, get out and lower trailer onto ball, move latch to lock on ball, hook up electric and chains. Kingpin, back straight in and click, tug test, done. Hook up electric, done. No need to use safety chains with kingpin either as it is considered a positive locking hitch(kingpin). Alignment to hook up is also not as critical.
 

M and E

Well-known member
kingpin vs ball. one motion to lock in. With ball you must stop very close to center of socket on trailer, get out and lower trailer onto ball, move latch to lock on ball, hook up electric and chains. Kingpin, back straight in and click, tug test, done. Hook up electric, done. No need to use safety chains with kingpin either as it is considered a positive locking hitch(kingpin). Alignment to hook up is also not as critical.
Thanks @Bozo! I'm wondering if others have a different opinion on hookup? Also, I'm wondering of others agree with the hookup of a goose being more difficult but feel its worth the trouble for whatever their reasons are.
 

Bozo

Well-known member
Thanks @Bozo! I'm wondering if others have a different opinion on hookup? Also, I'm wondering of others agree with the hookup of a goose being more difficult but feel its worth the trouble for whatever their reasons are.
I can see some prefer goose if they are just weekending and needing truck to haul large items home to their sticks and bricks home or if they are close on payload capacity due to pin weight. My situation is not that. My dually is dedicated tow mule. I have a flatbed 3500 for any other hauling chores not requiring a trailer. I also find that people do not ask t borrow my gooseneck trailers anymore either….wrong hook up for them. For those wanting to keep their bed free of hitch, again, I wholeheartedly recommend the goose box. Only thing I don’t like about those is the fact of that structure hanging under the trailer where I like to put my bikes and such. Still have safety chains too.
 
Top